top of page
Search

Authenticity as a Strategy: The Competitive Advantage Most Companies Are Missing

guy listening to music at desk

Several years ago, I was leading a massive nine-month RFP process for a growing segment of our business. After months of presentations, evaluations, spreadsheets, and meetings, we narrowed it down to two companies.


And honestly?


On paper, they were basically tied.


Same capabilities.

Similar pricing.

Strong leadership teams.


There was no obvious winner.


But the experience of working with them felt completely different.


One company did everything “right.” Polished presentations. Corporate messaging. Executive networking. Every interaction felt carefully managed.


The other company? They felt human.


Their CEO opened the finalist presentation with a story. Their follow-up emails sounded like real people wrote them. They answered questions directly instead of hiding behind buzzwords.


And that’s who we chose.


Not because they were wildly different technically.

Because we trusted them more.


That moment reinforced something I now believe deeply:


Authenticity isn’t just a personality trait. It’s a business strategy.



What Authenticity in Business Actually Means


Let’s clear something up.


Authenticity at work does not mean:

  • saying every thought in your head

  • oversharing

  • “just being yourself” without boundaries


Authenticity is about doing what’s needed, not what’s normal.


It’s about communicating like a human in environments that often reward sounding robotic.


Organizations that embrace authenticity in the workplace tend to:

  • ditch unnecessary corporate jargon

  • use stories instead of endless slides

  • treat humility as a strength instead of a weakness


And while those things sound simple, they’re surprisingly rare.


Which is exactly why they stand out.



How Authentic Leadership Changed My Company


About six months after that RFP process, I became CEO of the company.


At the time, we had:

  • five straight years of flat growth

  • low morale

  • declining energy across the organization


And I didn’t have some fancy McKinsey playbook to fix it.


So I leaned harder into authenticity as a strategy.


I stopped hiding behind polished executive communications.

I wrote employee emails myself.

I opened town halls with stories instead of corporate updates.

I admitted mistakes openly.


At company events, I skipped the executive small talk, danced (badly), and stayed late to help clean up.


None of this was revolutionary.


But it was real.


And the impact was huge.


Within three years:

  • earnings tripled from $17 million to $50 million

  • employee engagement skyrocketed

  • trust and morale improved dramatically


People respect authority, but they follow authenticity.



Why Authenticity Matters Even More Now


Today, AI can generate:

  • emails

  • presentations

  • marketing copy

  • LinkedIn posts


in seconds.


Which means sounding polished is no longer impressive.


In fact, perfection often feels suspicious.


People are craving communication that feels human, direct, and real.


That’s why authenticity in business is no longer optional. It’s becoming one of the few true differentiators left.


The leaders and companies who stand out moving forward won’t necessarily be the most polished.


They’ll be the most believable.



Erin Hatzikostas is an internationally recognized leader on the impact of authenticity in the workplace. Learn more about her keynote speaking, workshops, and other authentic programs here.


 
 
bottom of page