top of page

It’s Never Too Late to Bring Authenticity Into a Conversation

2 days ago
4 min read
being silly during an interview

Have you ever been in an interview or meeting where something just feels… off?


You’re answering the questions. You’re saying all the “right” things. Everyone is being perfectly professional.


And yet, you’re thinking, Who the hell is this person talking? Because it certainly doesn’t feel like me.


That happened recently to a friend of mine. And what she did next is something I want more people to try.


Because sometimes, the best way to bring authenticity into a conversation isn’t to start over.


It’s simply to call out what’s happening.


When an interview starts feeling fake


My friend has been on the interview circuit lately, and she’s a big believer in authenticity as a strategy. She’s read both of my books, we run together, and she’s constantly telling me about the ways she’s using what I teach.


One of the things she knows to do is bring authenticity into a conversation as early as possible.


Tell a story. Share a humility moment. Say something unexpected. Give people a glimpse of the actual human sitting across from them.


It works because it changes the dynamic. People relax. They become more curious. And suddenly, you’re having an actual conversation instead of participating in some corporate version of The Dating Game.


But sometimes you don't get that opportunity right away.


That’s what happened to her.


She jumped onto an interview call expecting a normal conversation and quickly realized it was a huge panel.


Uh-oh.


Suddenly, there were a bunch of people asking questions, everyone was being very buttoned-up, and the whole thing started to feel like people were cosplaying as interviewers.


And let's be honest: Most of us do this.


It’s not because people are boring or stuffy. They simply don’t always know how to behave when they’re in a formal situation. So everyone gets a little more polished, a little more careful, and a lot less human.


My friend started answering the questions, but she didn't feel like herself.


And that matters.


Because when you’re interviewing for a job, you don’t just want to demonstrate that you can do the work. You want people to see you. Your personality. Your perspective. The thing that makes you different from every other qualified candidate.


She knew she wasn't showing that.


So halfway through the interview, she did something incredibly simple… she called it out.


She said something along the lines of:


“Hey, just so you know, I didn’t quite realize this was going to be such a big panel, and I know I’ve felt a little awkward.”


That was it.


She didn't make a big production out of it. She didn't apologize profusely. She just acknowledged what was actually happening.


And guess what happened next?


Everyone relaxed.


The shoulders went down. The smiles went up. The conversation became more natural.


And she started feeling like herself again.


The power of saying what everyone is thinking


This is one of my favorite authenticity hacks because it’s so simple.


Tell the truth about the moment you're actually in.


We spend so much time trying to pretend we're not nervous, awkward, uncomfortable, confused, or thrown off.


But here's the thing: everyone else can usually feel it anyway.


So instead of trying harder to hide it, what if you just name it?

  • “This is a lot of people!”

  • “I didn't expect this to be a panel.”

  • “I'm realizing I'm a little nervous because this is something I really care about.”

  • “I feel like we're getting a little too deep into the weeds here. Can I take a step back?”


Those little moments can completely change the energy in a room.


Because authenticity gives everyone else permission to be human, too.


Start with authenticity when you can. But don't panic if you don't.


I still believe the best time to bring authenticity into a conversation is early.


If you can open an interview with a story, share a humility moment, or find some other way to break through the corporate polish, do it.


You’ll often change the dynamic before the awkwardness has a chance to take over.


But sometimes that doesn't happen.


Maybe you didn't know who would be in the meeting. Maybe the interviewer is particularly formal. Maybe everyone is nervous. Maybe you're 20 minutes in before you realize, Wow. I have not sounded like myself once.


That's okay.


It is never too late.


You don't have to keep playing along with an interaction that feels inauthentic just because that's how it started.


You can change the energy at any point.


Sometimes all it takes is telling the truth about what you're experiencing.


And ironically, that little moment of vulnerability might be exactly what makes everyone else feel comfortable enough to drop the act, too.


So the next time you're in an interview, meeting, presentation, or even a networking conversation and you're thinking, This feels weird, don't assume you've blown it.


You might just need to say so.


Because authenticity isn't about getting everything right from the first second.

It's about having the courage to bring the real you into the room—even when you didn't quite start that way.




Erin Hatzikostas is an internationally recognized leader on the impact of authenticity in the workplace. Learn more about her keynote speaking, workshops, and other authentic programs here.

 
 
bottom of page